Your spot to relax
Experience Pagliacci Pizza
Pagliacci Pizza, located in Seattle on Rainier Ave S, stands out for its unforgettable pizza experience. Known for its perfectly crisp yet fluffy crust and vibrant toppings, this pizzeria invites pizza lovers to indulge in a variety of flavors, including unique seasonal offerings like peach prosciutto. Customers describe the atmosphere as warm and inviting, complemented by friendly and efficient staff. Despite some remarks on pricing and parking challenges, the quality of the pizza, highlighted by fresh ingredients and homemade sauce, makes every visit worthwhile. With a commitment to excellence, Pagliacci Pizza is a staple in Seattle's culinary scene.
Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Pagliaccio Salad
Pesto Salad
Caesar Salad
Inside the Experience
Pagliacci Pizza
Welcome to Pagliacci Pizza, a beloved gem nestled in the vibrant heart of Seattle at 4901 Rainier Ave S. For pizza lovers seeking not just a meal, but a delightful experience, Pagliacci Pizza checks all the boxes. With an enticing menu that focuses on fresh ingredients and unique flavor profiles, this spot has carved out a reputation worth exploring.
Stepping into Pagliacci, you'll immediately feel the warm, welcoming vibe. Reviewers rave about the friendly service and the bustling atmosphere that makes for a perfect dining environment. The staff here are dedicated to ensuring that every visit is memorable, whether you're dining in or taking your pizza to go. From the moment you walk in, you sense you're part of a community that values quality and satisfaction.
Now, let’s talk about the pizza. The crust is a standout feature—crispy on the outside yet soft and chewy inside, an ideal base for the array of fresh toppings they expertly layer on. Reviewers have highlighted favorites like the double pepperoni and Italiano slices. The latter, with its roast garlic and spinach, has received praise for being a less traditional yet delightful option. For those on a gluten-free diet, the gluten-free crust has also surprised many, lauded for its enjoyable texture and flavor.
Seasonal offerings, like the peach prosciutto pizza, showcase Pagliacci’s commitment to creativity and freshness. Diners have noted how these seasonal innovations keep the menu exciting and cater to diverse palates. And if you’re not in the mood for pizza? The Caesar salad is a fresh, crisp complement to your meal.
While some find the prices on the higher side, many agree that the quality justifies the expense. A meal here not only fulfills your appetite but provides a satisfying experience that’s hard to replicate elsewhere in Seattle. Plus, the parking situation, though occasionally a challenge, is generally manageable, allowing you to focus on enjoying your time and meal.
Beyond the food, Pagliacci Pizza embraces events and community engagement, as demonstrated during their two-free-slices giveaway—an initiative that brought smiles to many faces and showcased their stellar service even during busy times.
In essence, Pagliacci Pizza is more than just a place to grab a slice; it’s a destination where flavor meets fun, and community is fostered through shared meals. With an impressive blend of classic and creative offerings, this pizza spot earns its place as a favorite for locals and visitors alike. Whether you’re a newcomer or a returning fan, every visit promises something special.
What Guests Say
Guestbook
“ Wasn’t sure if we came here for pizza or an oil change. My kids bet on how many napkins it’d take to soak up one slice—answer: five. EACH. Great service, good atmosphere, shockingly good parking!!! But $30+ for a large pizza (with a guilt-trip tip screen)? Final verdict: bring your appetite, your wallet, and a roll of Bounty. ”
“ Free slices of Pie, I got double pepperoni and Italiano slice. The double pepperoni was too salty and grease, that made sense. The Italiano was better. I did not think I was going to like it. It has roast garlic and Spinach. There was only one spinach, may be that why I like it better. Never heard of the place before and came here to try their pizza. ”
“ Parking can be a little sus at times depending on events nearby, but it's definitely worth the extra time to find parking. There aren't too many places left in Seattle where you can get a good meal under $10, but this is one of them. Their seasonal pizzas are my favorite; especially the peach prosciutto and hamburger pizza. My favorite part about this place is the freshness and quality of the ingredients. I love pizza, but I generally don't have it very often because I'm sensitive to gluten. Normally, I feel like crap after I have pizza, but I've never had that issue here. I'm not even ordering the gluten free pizza, I just get a slice or 2 to go. ”
“ Pagliacci Pizza was absolutely fantastic! On Summer Solstice (June 21st, 2025), they offered a two-free-slices giveaway, and despite the huge line outside the store, the service was impressively fast and efficient. Everyone was able to get their slices with ease — the team did a wonderful job keeping things moving smoothly. The pizza itself was delicious. I loved the thin crust, and the vegetarian pizza was a real standout with generous chunks of garlic that made the flavor absolutely amazing. Definitely a must-try for any pizza lover! ”
“ Pagliacci never disappoints. The crust is perfectly crisp on the outside and soft inside, the toppings are fresh and full of flavor, and the sauce tastes homemade. The staff are always friendly and quick, and the restaurant has a warm, welcoming vibe. Delivery is fast, and the quality is just as good as dining in. Definitely my go-to pizza spot in Seattle — consistently delicious and worth every bite! ”